Letter to the Editor: Bears Ears National Monument

Submitted by Randy Keller

Dear Editor,

The comment period on reconsideration of the Bears Ears National Monument is open and will close on May 26. This monument was created by President Obama over the objections of the local county governments affected by the land withdrawal. It occurs to me that engaging in dialogue over these types of issues with respect and a willingness to compromise to protect everyone’s important values, could chart a path away from the divisive and destructive politics that prevail in our nation today. Anyway, my comment follows.

Withdrawals of federal land have tremendous impacts on communities in those areas. Impacts may be positive or negative. Such withdrawals should not be accomplished without the utmost respect for the culture, economics and wisdom of the people who live near and who will experience the consequences of the withdrawal. Accordingly, a fair federal policy concerning community impacts should be implemented. I suggest that no withdrawal of federal land should be implemented without the approval of the local communities, as indicated by approval of affected county and tribal governments.

This would have many positive impacts. Most importantly, it would show respect for local communities and culture, which are ordinarily minority interests compared to the urban constituency that often drives federal land decisions. It would empower local advocacy groups (environmental and others) to advocate their causes in local communities, where a decision would have meaning. It would encourage meaningful compromise and protection of local interests, which ordinarily include a strong land ethic. It would begin to bridge the gap between urban and rural interests which seem to be so divisive in our national politics.

Undoubtedly, national level urban constituencies have the power to make federal land use policy without consideration of minority rural interests. Restraining this power would show proper respect for the culture and vibrancy of the less powerful communities of our nation, which coincidentally cover the greatest area of the country. Great power should not be used to the detriment of fragile communities. It is time for true dialogue and compromise among our various communities – rather than vanquishment of the one by the other. Perhaps this could begin a process by which we protect both our precious lands and our precious communities.

Comments can be made at: https://www.regulations.gov/document?D=DOI-2017-0002-0001.

Randy Keller

Bishop, California

4 Responses to Letter to the Editor: Bears Ears National Monument

  1. CarbonFootPrint May 19, 2017 at 6:30 pm #

    I could not have said this better myself. Thank you for taking the time and effort to write this letter. You hit the nail on the head. We locals need a greater say on what directly affects us. Yes, the land belongs to all Americans. But when decisions are made by people from far away that have a detrimental impact on the local residents, that’s wrong. Local people know what’s good for them. We don’t need the nanny state telling us what’s wrong or what’s right.

  2. Paco May 19, 2017 at 11:26 am #

    Let’s also remember that many times the locals do way more damage to the landscape than the big bad government. Take the current destruction of wetlands at Mono Lake by the cretins at the Tioga Lodge, for example. Had not a Mono Lake Committee person seen what was going on and reported it, the damage would have been far, far greater than the extensive damage done before Mono County halted it.

    Sometimes the “local wisdom” isn’t so wise after all.

  3. Jen Roeser May 18, 2017 at 8:39 pm #

    Very well written. Thank you

  4. Charles O. Jones May 18, 2017 at 1:08 pm #

    Sure, consideration to local interests should always be given a high priority. But public lands belong to everyone, not just to those who live in the vicinity. Loud local voices and/or those with economic interests shouldn’t be the only ones controlling decisions regarding the lands that belong to all Americans.


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.